| Platinum | Dave and Charlies Hometown Deli |
| Gold | Cranbury Market |
| Silver | BLT Deli |
| Bronze | Duchess Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Blue Cactus Grill |
| Top Pick | Garden Catering - Norwalk |
| Top Pick | Jersy Mike's |
| Top Pick | Jimmy John's |
| Top Pick | Silver Star Restaurant-Diner |
| Top Pick | The Dilly Duck Shop |
| Gold's Delicatessen |