| Platinum | Slice of Italy |
| Gold | Planet Pizza |
| Silver | Romanacci |
| Bronze | Jordan's Restaurant & Pizza |
| Top Pick | BJ Ryan's East |
| Top Pick | Coals |
| Top Pick | Colony Grill |
| Top Pick | Letizia's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Massimo's Italian Corner |
| Top Pick | Norwalk Pizza & Pasta |
| Tarantino Restaurant |